Perspectives on Barriers to Peoples Participation in Watershed Management Plans in South of Arad, the Ray County

Document Type : Research

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Soil Conservation and Watershed Management Research Institute, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Tehran, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Soil Conservation and Watershed Management Research Institute, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Understanding the barriers in achieving people¢s persistent participation, resolving problems and participating in watershed management plans have an important role to play in increasing the effectiveness of the watershed management plans and reducing the related costs. Arad district is located in Ray County, the Province of Tehran, and is one of such areas where has been implemented the operational proposals from detailed studies of watershed management implemented. Several factors may contribute to a lack of people¢s participation in watershed management plans. These factors were identified by experts based on desk studies, queries from experts, as well as face-to-face interviews with residents of the area as four indicators and 11 sub-indicators, whereby their validity were confirmed by experts. These indicators were prioritized based on the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process method as well as the Friedman nonparametric test based on the expert group (28 experts) and the residents based on the sample size derived from Cochrane's formula (220 locals). The two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was also used to examine the agreement of the two views on the importance of the items. The range of consistency ratio of judgments and Cronbach's alpha varied from 0.035 to 0.079 and 0.710 to 0.815, respectively. Accordingly, the priority of effective indicators and sub-indicators on a lack of people participation from the viewpoint of expert and residents from the importance of high to low were determined and an agreement of the views was established. It is suggested that the solutions to remove the barriers of participation, be considered in the future detailed studies of watershed management in the study area based on the priorities presented in this investigation.

Keywords

References

Abdolmaleki M, Pezeshki-Rad GHR, Chizari M. 2007. An investigation on short term extension and educational courses relating to ranch owners in Tuyserkan Township, Iran. Journal of Agricultural Sciences Islamic Azad University. 1(13): 39–53 (In Persian).
Agidew AMA, Singh KN. 2018. Factors affecting farmers’ participation in watershed management programs in the Northeastern highlands of Ethiopia: A case study in the Teleyayen Sub-Watershed. Ecological Processes, 7(1): 1–15.
Ahmadi Osquoi A, Heidari Gh, Mahdavi SKh. 2012. Investigating the factors affecting the level of beneficiaries' willingness to conclude rangeland plans from the expert's viewpoint (Case study: Rangelands of Bojnourd County), Natural Ecosystems of Iran, 3 (1): 101–112. (In Persian).
Amir Nejad H, Rafiei H. 2010. The effect of socioeconomic factors on farmers' participation in rangeland projects. Rangeland, 3)4(: 710–722. (In Persian).
Apipoonyanon C, Kuwornu K, Szabo S, Shrestha, RP. 2020. Factors influencing household participation in community forest management: Evidence from Udon Thani Province, Thailand. Journal of Sustainable Forestry, 39(2): 184–206.
Bagdi GL, Kurothe RS. 2014. People’s participation in watershed management programmers: Evaluation study of Vidarbha region of Maharashtra in India. International Soil and Water Conservation Research, 2(3): 57–66.
Bagherian R. 2009. Community participation in watershed management programs. Journal of Social Sciences, 5(3): 251–256.
Bagherian R, Bahaman AS, Asnarulkhadi AS, Shamsuddin A. 2009. A socio exchange approach to people’s participation in watershed management programs in Iran. European Journal of Scientific Research. 34(3): 428–441.
Chen J. 2020. Integrated management of the Yangtze River Basin. In evolution and water resources utilization of the Yangtze river. Springer, Singapore.
Clayton A, Oakley P, Pratt B. 1998. Empowering people: A guide to participation. United Nations Development Programmed.
Dodds R. 2020. Using a participatory integrated watershed management approach for tourism. Tourism Planning & Development, 17(1): 1–16.
Duram LA, Brown KG. 1999. Insights and applications assessing public participation in US watershed planning initiatives. Society & Natural Resources, 12(5): 455–467.
Feiznia S, Salehpour Jam A, Kianian MK. 2006. Investigation of preventing factors affecting on people participation in natural resources plans (Case study: Roude Shoor Watershed Area). Journal of Mountainous Environment, 6(1): 12–26. (In Persian).
General Department of Natural Resources and Watershed Management of Tehran Province. 2011. Report of detailed studies of watershed management, South Arad watershed, Ray County. General Department of Natural Resources and Watershed Management, Tehran, 180 p. (In Persian).
George D, Mallery P. 2003. SPSS for Windows step by step: A simple guide and reference, 11.0 update (4th ed.), Allyn and Bacon, Boston. 357 p.
Habibpour Gatabi K, Safari Shali R. 2016. Comprehensive manual for using SPSS in survey researches, Louyeh press, Tehran. (In Persian).
Hassanzadeh Nafuti M, Khorasani Anari A, Jamali AA. 2013. Evaluation of factors affecting the rate of public participation in implementation of watershed management plans (Case study: Nahrain Dam Watershed, Tabas City), First National Conference on the Application of New Science and Technologies in Agriculture and Natural Resources, Maybod, Islamic Azad University of Maybod. (In Persian).
Heyd H, Neef A. 2006. Public participation in water management in northern Thai highlands. Water Policy, 8(5) :395–413.
Jamshidi AR, Amini AM. 2013. Evaluation of factors affecting on natural resource degradation from the viewpoint of expert’s management of natural resources in Ilam Province, Journal of Conservation and Utilization of Natural Resources, 1(4): 91–105. (In Persian).
Khalili V, Mahmoudi J, Gholami ShA, Nazari M. 2015. Factors affecting the rate of participation of beneficiaries in the implementation Range Management Plan (Case study of summer pastures Vazroud Area). Natural Ecosystems of Iran, 5(2): 105–113. (In Persian).
Karimi Sangchini E, Ownegh M, Sadoddin A, Tahmasebipuor N, Rezaee H. 2018. An investigation on affecting factors on community participation and predicting the community acceptance of the vegetation-based management scenarios for the Hable-rud River Basin. Watershed Engineering and Management, 10)3(: 280–293. (In Persian).
Mansourfar K. 2006. Advanced methods of statistics with computer programs, University of Tehran Press, Tehran. 480 p. (In Persian).
Mansouri A, Salehpourjam A, Mohammadi M, Kianian MK. 2016. Investigation and prioritizing preventing factors of people participation in natural resources plans (case study: Kan Watershed area, Tehran, Iran), 2th national conference on conservation of natural resources and environment, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil. (In Persian).
Moghadam R, Dinpanah Gh, Zand F. 2013. Factors influence on economic- social effectiveness of watershed and natural resources plans. European Journal of Experimental Biology, 3(5): 400–406.
Mosaffaie J. 2020. Identification and prioritization of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans case study (Niarij Watershed of Qazvin Province). SCWMRI, Final Report, Tehran, Iran. (In Persian).
Moussaie M, Malek Mohammadi I, Farajollah Hosseini SJ, Miramadi SM. 2009. Factores impacting stakeholders participation in watershed management projects in Fars Province in Iran. 5th National Conference on Watershed Management Science and Engineering (Sustainable Natural Disaster Management), Faculty of Agriculture and Natural Resources, Gorgan, Iran. (In Persian).
Nigussie Z, Tsunekawa A, Haregeweyn N, Adgo E, Cochrane L, Floquet A, Abele S. 2018. Applying Ostrom’s institutional analysis and development framework to soil and water conservation activities in north-western Ethiopia. Land Use Policy, 71: 1–10.
Prokopy LS. 2005. The relationship between participation and project outcomes: audience from rural water supply projects in India. Journal of World Development, 33(11): 1801–1819.
Rezai R, Vadadi E, Mehrdoost Kh. 2012. Investigating factors influencing villagers' participation in khomarak watershed management plans (Case study: Deh Jalal Village), Journal of Rural Research, 3(1): 199–221 (In Persian).
Rouhi F, Amirnejad H, Heidari Gh, Ghorbani Pashaklai J. 2011. Investigating the role of farmers' social factors on their participation in rangeland plans (Case study: Rangelands of Ghaemshahr County). Rangeland, 4)3(: 474–483. (In Persian).
Saaty T. 1980. The analytical hierarchy process, planning, priority, Resource Allocation, Rws pub, USA. 287 p.
Salehi L. 2007. Investigation of effective factors on people participation in watershed management plans. 4th International Conference of Watershed Management, University of Tehran. (In Persian).
Salehpour Jam A, Karimpour Reihan M, Kianian MK, Tajiki M. 2012. Investigation of preventing factors affecting on people participation in natural resources plans (Case study: Ghoochak - Roudak Area, Tehran, Iran), 1th national desert conference, University of Tehran, Tehran. (In Persian).
Salehpour Jam A, Rasooli F, Sarreshtehdari A, Mosaffaie J, Kianian MK. 2020. Prioritization of preventing social indices affecting on peoples' participation in natural resources plans using AHP method and nonparametric tests. Watershed Engineering and Management, 12)1(: 225–239. (In Persian).
Salehpour Jam A, Sarreshtehdari A, Tabatabaei M. 2018. Prioritizing preventing factors affecting on stakeholders 'participation in watershed plans based on experts'idea. (Case study: Watershed Area Surrounding City of Tehran. Watershed Engineering and Management, 9)4(: 441–450. (In Persian).
Samanta RK, Jana, NC. 2020. The role of participation of people in watershed management–a study from Ausgram Block–II of Bardhhaman district, west Bengal. Studies in Indian Place Names, 40(70): 4043–4054.
Singleton A, Taylor M. 1992. Common property, collective action and community. J. Theory. Pol. 4(3): 309–324.
Sharma C, Sisodia SS. 2016. Peoples’ participation in watershed development programmer: A case study of Rajasthan. Indian Research Journal of Extension Education, 8(1): 71–72.
Soleimanpour SM, Salehpour Jam A, Noroozi AA, Khalili N. 2020. Investigation of stakeholders in prioritizing factors affecting their poor participation in watershed management projects (Case study: Morad Abad Watershed in Meymand, Fars Province). Journal of Range and Watershed Management, 72)4(: 979–994. (In Persian).
Soleimanpour SM, Salehpour Jam A, Noroozi AA, Khalili N, Keshavarzi H. 2019. Experts' viewpoints on prioritizing factors affecting lack of sustainable participation of rural communities in watershed management projects on the Moradabad Watershed, Meymand the Province of Fars. Watershed Management Research, 32)3(: 53–62. (In Persian).
Sultana F. 2009. Community and participation in water resources management: gendering and naturing development debates from Bangladesh. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 34(3): 346–363.
Werts JD, Mikhailova EA, Post CJ, Sharp JL. 2012. An integrated Web GIS framework for volunteered geographic information and social media in soil and water conservation. Environmental Management, 49(4):816–832.
Zarei M, Azmoodeh A, Amirnejad H. 2013. Investigation of factors affecting non-participation of users in watershed management projects (Case study: Berenjestanak Watershed). Natural Resources Economics, 2(1): 101–112. (In Persian).

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 26 February 2020
  • Revise Date: 21 April 2020
  • Accept Date: 30 May 2020

Share

How to cite

Statistics